• English
  • Русский

Saussure and Bakhtin

F. de Saussure determined rigid limits of priorities in linguistics and separated language from speech that has no system in his opinion. M. M. Bakhtin in his work «The Problem of Speech Genres» accepted the differentiation of language and speech (utterance in his system of terms) unlike V. N. Voloshinov but he considered the concentration on the problems of language insufficient and the study of speech necessary. In the field of speech he singled out the most stable component – speech genres that are set to speakers together with language.

Now there are two opposite, but often co-existing trends. On the one hand, we see the desire for scientific rigor, especially in experimental and applied research. By a purely linguistic study of the functioning of language, linguists also try to rely on some stable characteristics, among which, of course, are speech genres. On the other hand, many linguists, compared with the previous period, have a level of scientific rigor which has decreased. In general, in modern Russia the functional linguistics is far from the principles which F. de Saussure relied on.  And among the precursors of functionalism, Mikhail Bakhtin undoubtedly took an important place.

The modern functional linguistics took Saussure’s limits away and expanded the object of studies including speech genres.

Bibliography

1. Bakhtin M. M. Problema rechevykh zhanrov [The Problem of speech genres]. Bachtin M. M. Sobranie sochinenij: v 5 t. [Collected works: in 5 vol.]. Vol. 5. Мoscow, 1996, pp. 159–206.

2. Smirnitskiy A. I. Ob'yektivnost' sushchestvovaniya yazyka [Objectiveness of existence of the language]. Moscow, 1954. 33 p.

3. Saussure F. de. Kurs obshchey lingvistiki  [Course of General Linguistics]. Saussure F. de. Trudy po yazykoznaniyu [Works on linguistics]. Moscow, 1977. 695 p.

4. Yakubinskiy L. P. F. de Sossyur o nevozmozhnosti yazykovoy politiki  [F. de Saussure about the impossibility of language policy]. Yazykovedeniye i materializm [Linguistics and materialism]. Iss. 2. Moscow, 1931, pp. 23–67.

5. Kholodovich A. A. F. de Sossyur  [Ferdinand de Saussure]. Saussure F. de. Trudy po yazykoznaniyu [Works on linguistics]. Moscow, 1977, pp. 9–30.

6. Balli Sh. Yazyk i zhizn' [Language and life]. Moscow, 2003 [1913]. 232 p.

7. Voloshinov V. Filosofiya i sotsiologiya gumanitarnykh nauk [Philosophy and Sociology Humanities]. St.-Petersburg, 1995. 382 p.

8. Iz perepiski M. M. Bakhtina i V. V. Kozhinova (1960-1966) [From the correspondence of Mikhail Bakhtin and V. V. Kozhinov (1960-1966)]. Dialog. Karnaval. Khronotop [Dialogue. Carnival. Chronotope]. 2000, no. 3–4, pp. 180–200.

9. Bakhtin Mikhail. Avtor i geroy. K filosofskim osnovam gumanitarnykh nauk [Author and hero. By the philosophical foundations of the humanities]. St.-Petersburg, 2000. 337 p.

10. Seshe A. Tri sossyurovskikh lingvistiki  [Three Saussurian linguistics]. Zvegintsev V.A. Istoriya yazykoznaniya XIX i XX vekov v ocherkakh i izvlecheniyakh [History of linguistics XIX and XX centuries in the essays and extracts]. Part II. Moscow, 1965, pp. 60–84.

11. Alpatov V. M. Iz istorii lingvistiki. Gardiner i Voloshinov [From the history of linguistics. Gardiner and Voloshinov]. Yazyki mira. Tipologiya. Uralistika. Pamyati T. Zhdanovoy [Languages ​​of the World. Typology. Uralic. Memory T. Zhdanova]. Moscow, 2002, pp. 15–22.

12. Alpatov V. M. Voloshinov, Bakhtin i lingvistika [Voloshinov, Bakhtin and Linguistics]. Moscow, 2005. 402 p.

13. Gardiner A. The Theory of Speech and Language. Oxford, 1932. 332 p.

14. Brandist C. On the Philosophical Sources of the Bakhtinian Theory of Dialogue and the Utterance. Bakhtin and his Intellectual Ambience. Gdańsk, 2002, pp. 43–61.

15. Stalin I. V. Marksizm i voprosy yazykoznaniya [Marxism and Problems of Linguistics]. Moscow, 1950. 114 p.

16. Mel'chuk I. A. Opyt teorii lingvisticheskikh modeley «Smysl Û Tekst». Semantika, sintaksis [Experience of linguistic models of the theory of «Meaning Û Text». The semantics, syntax]. Moscow, 1974. 256 p.

17. Nikolayeva T. M. Lingvistika teksta. Sovremennoye sostoyaniye i perspektivy [Text Linguistics. Current state and prospects]. Novoye v lingvistike [New in linguistics]. Iss. VIII. Lingvistika teksta. Moscow, 1978, pp. 5–42.

18. Kibrik A. Ye. Lingvisticheskiye postulaty  [Linguistic postulates]. Kibrik A. Ye. Ocherki po obshchim i prikladnym voprosam yazykoznaniya [Essays on general and applied linguistics issues]. Moscow, 1992 [1983]. 336 p.

Full Text (PDF):
(downloads: 214)